Skip to main content
How to Choose a Criminal Lawyer in NYC
If you’ve been charged with a crime in New York City, you already know how overwhelming the situation feels. The system moves fast, the stakes are high, and the choices you make early on can shape the outcome of your case. One of the most important decisions you’ll ever make is choosing the right criminal defense lawyer.
In a city filled with thousands of attorneys, finding the right one can feel impossible. But if you know what to look for—and what to avoid—you can find someone who will protect your rights and fight for your future.
Here’s how to choose a criminal lawyer in NYC who’s the right fit for you and your case.
1. Look for Experience in NYC Criminal Courts
Criminal defense is not one-size-fits-all. New York City’s criminal courts are unique—each borough has its own prosecutors, judges, and courtroom procedures. A lawyer who practices regularly in Manhattan Criminal Court will know how things run there, just as a Brooklyn or Queens defense attorney will have a sense of how those judges think.
When you’re facing criminal charges, local experience matters. You want a lawyer who has appeared in the exact courthouse where your case is being heard, knows how to navigate arraignments, and understands how the local DAs approach plea deals and trial strategy.
Ask any potential lawyer where they’ve tried cases and how often they appear in the borough where your case is pending. If they hesitate or can’t give a clear answer, that’s a red flag.
2. Make Sure They Handle Your Type of Case
Criminal defense covers everything from DWI to assault to white-collar crimes and federal charges. Not every lawyer is equally comfortable handling every type of case.
If you’re charged with assault, you need someone who has defended similar violent crime cases. If you’re accused of drug possession or sale, you want someone who understands suppression motions and how to challenge police searches.
The same goes for more specialized charges like domestic violence, weapons possession, or theft. The best NYC criminal lawyers focus their practice on defense work—and ideally on the specific types of cases you’re facing.
3. Don’t Confuse Flash with Substance
You’ve probably seen lawyers advertising on the subway or claiming they “win every case.” The truth is, no lawyer wins every case. The criminal justice system doesn’t work that way.
Instead of being swayed by marketing slogans, focus on substance. Look at the lawyer’s actual case results and what clients say about working with them. Do they explain the process clearly? Do they seem honest about possible outcomes? Do they talk about fighting for you in court, not just “settling your case”?
A good defense lawyer won’t make false promises. They’ll give you a realistic picture of what to expect—and then they’ll do everything possible to get the best outcome.
4. Ask About Communication and Accessibility
When you’re facing criminal charges, communication is everything. You’ll have urgent questions, court dates to remember, and paperwork that can’t wait.
The best criminal lawyers in NYC make themselves available to their clients. They return calls. They respond to emails. They take time to explain what’s happening at each stage of your case.
During your initial consultation, pay attention to how the lawyer treats you. Do they rush you through the conversation? Or do they take time to listen and explain your options?
You want a lawyer who treats your case like it matters—because it does.
5. Ask How They Approach Plea Negotiations and Trial
Not every criminal case goes to trial. In fact, most cases in NYC are resolved through plea agreements. That’s why you need a lawyer who is both a skilled negotiator and a capable trial advocate.
Ask how they approach plea deals. Do they push clients into taking the first offer, or do they dig into the evidence and look for ways to challenge the case before talking about a plea?
Then ask about their trial experience. How many criminal cases have they actually taken to verdict? What kinds of results have they gotten? A lawyer who’s confident in the courtroom has leverage at the negotiating table—because prosecutors know they can’t bluff them.
6. Understand Fees and What You’re Paying For
Every defense lawyer handles billing differently. Some charge flat fees for certain types of cases; others bill hourly. Either way, make sure you understand what’s included before you sign anything.
A trustworthy NYC criminal lawyer will be upfront about costs. At Cody Warner, P.C., we publish our fees.
Don’t automatically go with the cheapest option. A low fee might sound appealing, but it often means less time spent on your case. What you’re paying for is skill, strategy, and commitment—qualities that can make all the difference in the outcome.
7. Pay Attention to Gut Instinct
After you’ve met with a few lawyers, you’ll start to get a feel for who you can trust. Listen to that instinct. You’re going to be working closely with this person—sometimes for months or even years.
You need to feel comfortable sharing personal details about your life and confident that they’ll have your back, no matter what happens.
If a lawyer talks down to you, doesn’t listen, or seems dismissive, move on. A strong defense requires teamwork between attorney and client.
8. Look for a Track Record of Respect—Not Just Results
Winning cases matters. But so does reputation. Judges, prosecutors, and even court staff know which lawyers come prepared and which ones don’t.
A lawyer who’s respected in the courtroom can often secure better plea deals, smoother negotiations, and fairer treatment for clients. That kind of respect comes from professionalism, preparation, and a history of strong advocacy.
When researching a lawyer, look for consistent reviews that mention professionalism, honesty, and communication—not just “we won.”
9. Choose a Lawyer Who Believes in You
At the heart of every great defense is trust. Your lawyer should believe in your right to a fair trial and be willing to stand up for you against the system.
Good lawyers don’t judge their clients. They defend them—relentlessly, within the bounds of the law. Whether you’re charged with a misdemeanor or a serious felony, your lawyer’s role is to protect your constitutional rights and fight for your future.
That kind of belief can make all the difference when the odds feel stacked against you.
Final Thoughts
Choosing a criminal lawyer in NYC is about more than finding someone with a law degree. It’s about finding an advocate—someone who knows the courts, understands the stakes, and is ready to fight for you.
Don’t rush the process. Meet with a few attorneys, ask hard questions, and trust your instincts. The right lawyer will make you feel informed, supported, and ready to face whatever comes next.
If you or a loved one are facing criminal charges in New York City, act fast. The earlier you have an experienced NYC criminal defense lawyer on your side, the more options you’ll have to protect your rights and your future. Contact Cody Warner, P.C. for a free consultation.